Sunday, April 27, 2025

Le Tour de France 2014 – Stage 10: Mulhouse – La Planche des Belles Filles, 161 km. Nibali Wins, Contador Crashes

-

HomeRaceRace ReviewsLe Tour de France 2014 - Stage 10: Mulhouse - La Planche...

La Planche des Belles Filles

La Planche des Belles Filles. Epic.

There’s no other word.

In any Saga there are heroes and villains; but the only one of the latter to manifest herself on this day was Lady Luck.

Lashing out spitefully at Alberto Contador and casting a second Grand Favourite from the Tour.

I can’t recall the last time I saw the Spaniard “chuck” a race so knew it was serious.

The Tinkoff press release says;

“Alberto crashed on a fast and straight part of the descent.

“He was reaching for his pocket and the bike was swept away under him probably because of a bump or hole in the road.

“Alberto was in the shape of his life and the entire team had our eyes fixed on the podium in Paris and the work we would have to do to get there.”

La Planche des Belles Filles
Contador gets his knee strapped up.

Following the crash Alberto received a new bike and medical treatment to stop the bleeding from his knee.

“After the crash, Alberto got back on the bike and we tried for about 18 kilometers to keep him in the race.

“Despite his best efforts and an impressive show of willpower, he had to abandon the race”, says Bjarne Riis after the stage.

“The captain of Tinkoff-Saxo was brought to the finish line in a team car and underwent medical examinations with x-rays being taken of the areas affected.

“Alberto has broken his tibia just below the knee. It’s not a complicated fracture but it probably requires surgery.

“He will stay with us tonight and tomorrow he will travel back to Madrid to undergo further examinations and a surgery if necessary”, adds Bjarne Riis.

“Alberto Contador’s exit is a tragic event also taken the many months of preparation into consideration together with the work that the team has done leading up to and during this year’s Tour.”

The word on Eurosport was that Contador’s frame had snapped – but as we all know, we can’t count on everything Carlton says.

But as I write this, Al Hamilton our man in Iberia has just sent us this;

Contador Crashes
Contador’s frame, snapped in two places. Photo©John MacLeary

“As a result of” or “the cause of” the crash?

However, Stephen Farrand tweeted;

It seems Contador’s spare bike on the car was broken after it got hooked up with the Belkin team car. Not related to the crash. #calmdown.

Contador Crashes
Well, it would appear to be the case that the bikes did indeed get tangled when on the roof racks. Photo©Joxean Matxin, taken from the back seat of the Lampre-Merida team car.

And Ivan tells us that the word from Lotto’s Jurgen Van Den Broeck is:

“According to JVDB, it was Alberto Contador’s own stupid fault that he fell, he sprinted past JVDB on a descent, hit a hole and went over the ‘bars, JVDB says he simply can’t understand why he took such a risk to move up one place on a descent.

“The story on CyclingNews website on Contador’s fall up to now has not mentioned JVDB’s comments (it has now, along with the fact that Contador may, in fact have crashed twice) only Bjarne Riis saying that the Spaniard was riding at 60 or 70 kph.”

Whatever the ‘whys and wherefores’ VeloVeritas wishes Alberto Contador a full and speedy recovery and this race will be the poorer without him.

Contador Crashes
Alberto says he may not need surgery but is unlikely to be better in time for the Vuelta.

Heroes?

Where to start?

QuickStep won’t win this Tour de France, they probably won’t make the podium – but they’ve attacked, enlivened and won.

Today they lost – but there’s ‘getting gubbed’ and ‘glorious failure,’ which was what today was for them in my book.

That man Tony Martin was at it again, towing team mate Michal Kwiatkowski over the vicious Vosges climbs; with the Pole at one stage ‘maillot jaune virtuel.’

But even Tony couldn’t put enough time into Nibali and his soldiers and when the German world champ ‘blew’ it was positively thermo nuclear.

Contador Crashes
Tony Martin towing Michael Kwiatkowski. Photo©B.Bade/ASO

Respect to Martin, Kwiatkowski and QuickStep – for their aggression, spectacle and riding ‘la course en tete.’

Nibali – for the second time in this race he made the best look flat footed, grabbed a brilliant stage win and claimed that most desirable of jerseys.

Today he was bright eyed but calm – not the tired looking rider who happily let yellow slip last night.

But one rider does not a team make; Fuglsang and Scarponi in particular were outstanding for Astana.

Contador Crashes
Scarponi did a job for Nibali today. Photo©B.Bade/ASO

The Italian did a Johny Helms cartoon type head first dive into the scenery on a tricky bend but picked himself up, hammered back up to his Capo then set the killing tempo for Nibali to launch from.

But for all their clinical stiletto work at the end of the stage, Astana did not drive immediately after Contador crashed – rivals’ chains coming off and punctures are one thing, but their hitting the tar at high speed is another.

It’s a long way to Paris but just like Wiggins in 2012 and Froome in 2013 it looks as if the stars are aligning for the Sicilian.

Contador Crashes
Gallopin did what he could today to hold onto yellow. Photo©B.Bade/ASO

Tony Gallopin lost the jersey today but there can be no shame, he rode himself inside out and cried at the finish at his losing the maillot jaune as his soigneur tried to console him – only the most cynical would not be moved.

(But I know Vik probably wouldn’t).

Rodriguez’s long hard day at least had it’s reward; he takes Tony Martin’s spotty jersey – and for a good part of the last climb it looked as if he was going to take the stage, too.

But it’s always easy to underestimate the rate at which a rampant top GC man eats up the tarmac between himself and a dying breakaway rider at the top of a mountain.

Contador Crashes
Rodriguez didn’t come to the Tour with the idea of being competitive – but he is coming into form nicely. Photo©B.Bade/ASO

And yesterday we said we’d wait until today before we run up the tricolour – head for that flagpole, guys!

There are four Frenchmen in the top 10 albeit Gallopin is only ‘passing through’ on his way back down the classement in fifth @ 3:12 after his adventures in yesterday’s successful big breakaway.

However, Bardet’s fourth spot @3:01; Pinot’s sixth @ 3:47 and Jean-Christophe Peraud’s eighth @ 3:57 are all solid and hard fought.

Pinot in particular was very impressive, putting 15 seconds into Valverde to take second on the stage behind Nibali.

Nibali leads Porte by 2:13 but 1:45 covers the rest of the top 10 – it’s going to be hand to hand combat for those podium places.

Crashes, rain, mountains – they deserve that rest day.

A demain.

Ed Hood
Ed Hood
Ed was involved in cycling for over 50 years. In that time he was a successful time triallist, a team manager and a sponsor of several teams and clubs. He was also a respected and successful coach and during the winter months often worked in the cabins at the Six Days for some of the world's top riders. Ed was a highly respected journalist, his tales of chasing the Giro, Tour, Vuelta, Classics and World Championships - and his much-loved winter Six Days - are legendary, never the same twice, they gave our site an edge other cycling media could never duplicate or challenge. Sadly Ed passed away in January 2025, two years after suffering a devastating stroke.

Related Articles

La Vuelta 2019 – Our Final Review

We look back at the final five stages of the Vuelta 2019, a great race with hardly a dull moment which saw the emergence of yet more tremendously talented youngsters.

Il Giro d’Italia 2014 – Stage 21; Gemona – Trieste, 169 km. Luka Mezgec Takes the Finale

Mezgec’s sprint was timed to perfection in what was a real free-for-all of a finish. And isn’t that Giant jersey livery just so effective? – there was no doubt about which kind of bike had just won as Big Luka crossed the line. Nacer Bouhanni (F des J & France) didn’t seem his usual desperate self, he said later he was too concerned about crossing the line upright and preserving his red points jersey.

La Vuelta a España 2014 – Stage 6; Benalmadena – Cumbres Verdes (La Zubia), 157.7 km. Alessandro Valverde Takes Over

Alessandro Valverde was hugely impressive – not the shadow of himself we saw in the last week of the Tour. It’s like Robert Millar said; ‘there comes a day when you have to stop dreaming.’ That day was yesterday for many as we were reminded of the savagery of professional bike racing at the highest levels. There were no interlopers – just the best of the best, all of the pre-race favourites trying their best to waste each other on that horrible grind to the line.

Tour de Trossachs 2007

Tour de Trossachs 2007 Mile zero: 09.54, and Alastair McNicol of Kelso Wheelers is on the line. Off No.1 at 10:01, he's not going to miss his start. It's six degrees, there are just wisps of cloud in the sky and Scotland has never looked better. Ferns, conifers and beech, lime green to dark brown form the backdrop for the timekeepers; to the north, the hills of the Trossachs wait quietly for the onslaught.

At Random

About Iñigo Cuesta and Gerard

Sunday, I did my hour on the bike this morning; had my shower, washed me vest and hat - time to amble down to the newsagents to pick up The Observer, just to see the prologue result in print; there might even be a paragraph or two, a mention of Iñigo Cuesta...but no - "nada."

Tour de Yorkshire 2018 – Stage 4 Wrap Up; Greg Van Avermaet takes the Stage and GC

Greg van Avermaet dedicated his stunning Tour de Yorkshire success to the memory of BMC Racing Team owner Andy Rihs after a superb final stage saw him crowned champion in Leeds. Rihs passed away at the age of 75 last month, with BMC still in mourning after losing a friend and passionate cycling fan as well as owner.

La Vuelta a España, Stage 15: Barredo First to Lagos de Covadonga

Carlos Barredo's grandmother wells up, 'my God, my God' she keeps repeating as Carlos's amigo hugs her - the man himself hurtled past just seconds ago to join the immortals as a winner on the Lagos de Covadonga. They're standing beside us at the 150m to go mark, and in the mist and cloud once again, QuickStep have done the job. The break survivors limp by before a snarling Ezequiel Mosquera flashes past, intent on putting as much time into the other 'heads' as he possibly can.

Tony Doyle – Britain’s Greatest Ever Six Day Rider

As a web site which tries to keep its readers in touch with what’s happening on the winter boards; it’s remiss of us not to have spoken before now to Britain’s greatest ever Six Day rider – Tony Doyle, MBE. Other ‘Brits’ rode the ‘races to nowhere’ – Tony Gowland even managed to win two Six Days (off 31 starts); London (with Patrick Sercu) and Montreal with (Gianni Motta).